Skip to main content

A Question of Fate


“Everyone is on a path that leads them (sic) to where they belong.”

That’s one of my favorite lines from The Mostly True Story of Jack by Kelly Barnhill, a story that looks into the ideas of magic, home and family, and, most important, fate.

Many fantasy novels use the idea of fate as a theme--characters are destined to be something or do something. Often the fate question is nicely woven into the plot; other times, it’s not. In a recent article in Entertainment Weekly Trey Parker and Matt Stone (speaking on how South Park episodes always have a lesson) said, “Plot should reveal the theme, and not vice versa.” Unfortunately, that’s not always the case in fantasy books.

Naruto (the manga and anime) deftly delves into questions regarding fate and destiny. At least two of the characters--Naruto and Gaara--have demons (real demons) inside of them. And they must decide if they will let the demons control them or if they will learn to control the demons--in essence, they must decide their own fates. Meanwhile, another character was sort of born into the wrong bloodline (one of ne’er do wells). His family isn’t supposed to have the heroes, but does that mean he can’t rise above that and become a hero? The Naruto stories do as Parker and Stone say. The plots are interesting and the story advances without the theme hitting you over the head.

Troubletwisters, by Garth Nix and Sean Williams, doesn’t handle the idea as nicely. I was so excited about this new series (I think Garth Nix’s “The Keys to the Kingdom” series is highly imaginative and recommend it to fantasy-loving teens). But Troubletwisters didn’t delight me at all. Worse, the authors use tease us about the fate of the two main characters. The "troubletwisters" of the title are twins who are just coming into their superpowers, if you will (check out the website: “Jack and Jaide’s destiny is about to unfold…”). But throughout this first book, the twins’ gifts and those of their family members are kept from them. They start to do strange things and strange things happen to them, but are told time and time again that they aren’t ready yet to learn the whys and wherefores. That doesn’t create suspense. It’s just annoying. Especially when their grandmother keeps calling them “troubletwisters” and yet refuses to tell them what that means. The conflict and action in this novel then relies on what the twins might be, not on what they’re doing.

Much better in dealing with characters’ fate is The Emerald Atlas, the first book in the new “Books of Beginning” series by John Stephens. The reader discovers the fate of the three children (and by fate here I mean destiny again and about how important they are to the fate of the world!) as they discover it. No one hints at it. Those that may know more than Kate, Michael, and Emma know aren’t really involved. And those that have an inkling are often just as surprised as the kids are as things unfold. The kids go on a quest and learn things about their past and about what they seem to be destined for. They are actively involved.

Best of all is The Mostly True Story of Jack. There are a few people who know about Jack's lineage and can explain mysterious happenings for him. But in this book, keeping the knowledge from him is woven into the story. At one point, Jack’s aunt suggests that they tell him everything. But his uncle says that isn’t reasonable: “My dear boy, if I were to tell you a wellspring of magic exists right beneath our feet, what would you say?” Jack replies: “I wouldn’t say anything, because that’s insane.” And later adds, “There’s no such thing as magic.”

Turns out Jack is magic. He’s the child of Mother Nature. In the end, Jack must decide if he’ll go back to her and prevent her from tearing the world apart. The story here is about Jack discovering who he is and deciding what to do about it.  

Comparisons can be made to “Harry Potter” (of course!!). Harry is told things slowly and finds out what he must do over the course of the seven novels. But I appreciate the fact that not too far into the first book Harry is told something straight by Hagrid: “You’re a wizard, Harry!” Thanks, Hagrid. Why keep us guessing?

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Harry vs. Septimus

Sometimes, I like the Septimus Heap series more than the Harry Potter series. There I said it. It’s a secret I’ve kept from all but my kids for a long time. Don’t get me wrong: I’m wild about Harry. I’ve knitted Harry Potter bookmarks (in Gryffindor colors, naturally). I’ve thrown at least two Harry Potter-themed birthday parties, complete with a sorting hat I made. I’ve stood at line overnight at Barnes and Noble waiting for the next book to come out three times. I read Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire  in one day. But, often, I like Angie Sage’s Septimus Heap books ( Magyk , Flyte , Physik , Queste , Syren , and the just published Darke ) more. And I’m not entirely sure why. My current theory is that the Septimus Heap books are better written and, while also highly derivative, much more charming. The characters are human (muggles, even) and fraught with faults. Also, the Harry Potter books are, rightly so, about Harry. Everything is from Harry’s perspective. Sadly, we don...

"The Story of Arthur Truluv" by Elizabeth Berg

I have a confession to make: You know that book Wonder by R.J. Palacio about the boy with facial deformities who attends public school for the first time and it's difficult for everyone involved, but in the end everyone's heart grows at least four sizes and we all feel good? I didn't love it. It's OK. And the movie was probably OK too. But as far as plot, character development, the style of the writing... I thought it was just OK. That's how I feel about The Story of Arthur Truluv , which is really all the things the various blurbs about the book says it is -- heartwarming, moving and sweet. You may even cry a little. But, unfortunately, it's like a much-watered-down version of A Man Called Ove by Fredrik Backman. Which is a far better book.   Arthur is too good. And Maddy's story is somewhat unbelievable (Why is she bullied? How does she get into the situation she gets into?) and too cliche (goth teen going to art school?). Lucille...

"The Book Thief" by Markus Zusak

At the end of The Return of the King , I sat in the movie theater and sobbed. Loud, embarrassing sobs. I loved the movies that much. See, each summer when I was a teen I'd re-read each of the books in The Lord of the Rings trilogy (and Little Women,  hoping each time Jo would change her mind and say yes to Laurie), so the books meant a lot to me and I was blown away by how well the movies turned out.  Walking out of the theater, I vowed never to see another movie again (until the next Harry Potter movie came out). Right now I feel I can never read another book. Not after reading The Book Thief . I got to the last few pages and just sobbed. The book, as many of you probably know, is about a young girl (the titular book thief) and her family in a small German town during World War II. I have read many World War II and holocaust novels. This book, narrated by Death, is the most human. Ostensibly, it's about words: how reading and writing can change us, and how words can be...